Brett Favre Rookie Cards | Your Market Guide

Brett Favre is one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history. He boasts a career with record-breaking stats, has played in championship games, and holds a Super Bowl title to his name.

Favre's achievements on the field can also translate into value for sports collectors who add some of the best Brett Favre rookie cards on the market to their collection. Like all the biggest names in the NFL, Brett Favre's rookie cards can fetch hundreds of dollars as they remain incredibly popular with collectors and hobbyists.

In this article, we dig deep into who Brett Favre is and explore the current fair market value for the best cards—helping you decide if Brett Favre rookie cards are something you want to pursue for your collection. We have a lot to get through, so let's get to it. 

Who Is Brett Favre? 

Brett Favre was a standout quarterback in college at the University of Southern Mississippi. In 1991, the Atlanta Falcons selected Favre early in the second round with the 33rd overall pick of the NFL Draft. However, his career didn't exactly race out of the gates, and he started slowly. 

He received minimal playing time in Atlanta and his debut season was anything but impressive. His coach even stated that it would "Take a plane crash for him to start Favre," a quote that would make him eat his words years later. 

After only one season in Georgia, Favre was then traded to the Green Bay Packers, where he'd become an NFL legend. Here, he earned the nickname "The Gunslinger," rewriting records in the process. He led the Packers to three NFC Championship games in a row, two Super Bowls, and helped lift the Lombardi Trophy at Super Bowl XXXI.

Fast-forward two decades, Favre is still considered one of the greatest quarterbacks to ever play the game. At the time of his 2010 retirement, Favre held several league records. To this day, he still owns the record for most consecutive games played with 299 in a row.

Named the NFL Most Valuable Player for three consecutive years, Favre was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2016. Undoubtedly, Favre was an incredible player, but how do his achievements translate into rookie cards?

Brett Favre Rookie Card - Market Value 

While his quarterback prowess is no secret, is there value in Brett Favre's rookie cards in the 21st century and beyond? Like with many cards, it depends on who you ask, but with numerous Brett Favre rookie cards on the market, the value will depend on quality, design, and current availability. 

Many rookie cards from various publishers highlight the different stages of Favre's career, including his short spell with the Falcons. With various designs, qualities, and rarity, let's discover some of the best and most lucrative cards for collectors and investors along with the fair market value for each.

The Best Brett Favre Rookie Cards 

1991 Topps Stadium Club Brett Favre #94

Sparking intrigue among collectors for years, the Topps Stadium Club Brett Favre #94 holds value differently from every other card on this list. It doesn't celebrate Favre's career or highlight a particular stage, but draws attention because of a printing error where Favre's last name is misspelled "Faver."

While not a perfect collector's item, this unique mistake can appeal to some collectors and bump its value. Plus, the card's uniqueness gives it a higher value than many others on this list. 

SportsCardsPro indicates grade 10 versions, on average, go for $275, and there are around three card sales per week. This is an intriguing stat if you're after one of these rare cards. 

On September 20, 2022, a Gem Mint grade 10 version of the card was sold for $350. According to Sports Cards Pro, even an ungraded version of this card is worth around $9.

1991 Pro Set Brett Favre #762

This is the most popular Brett Favre rookie card on the market. Unfortunately, its popularity doesn't mean it fulfills its potential in value, but it's still a classic card that makes a fantastic addition to any collection. The Pro Set contained the official NFL rookie cards for 1991, a point worth considering when looking at the monetary value of this particular Favre collectible. 

The card has a classic look. Simple and drastically different from the modern designs we see today. In addition, the 1991 Pro Set #762 was reproduced internationally, increasing its popularity to a broader global audience and bumping up its value. For example, the Spanish version of the card is popular among collectors. 

We checked the SportsCardsPro database to see how much this card was worth in 2022 and found an ungraded version worth $2, whereas a grade 10 edition of the card would go as high as $120. In addition, their database also indicated that prices had climbed even higher. For example, a grade 10 edition sold for $145.00 on September 15, 2022.

1991 Action Packed Brett Favre #21

This card is the perfect option if you're a new to the hobby and want to start a Brett Favre collection. A classic, hosting a rare action shot of him playing for the Falcons. (Look away, Packers fans). A picture many fans can hardly remember means this card has some rarity. 

We checked what the Action Packed #21 rookie card was worth in the market in 2022. According to the SportsCardsPro data, an ungraded edition of this card sells for around $3.75, while a grade 9 can fetch up to $22. But, get your hands on a Gem Mint grade 10, and numbers push as high as $82.79. Moreover, this Brett Favre rookie card has still been shown to go even higher. Sales data shows a handful of grade 10 versions selling for between $100 and $120 in January 2022. 

1991 Pacific Brett Favre #551 

It is striking nowadays because of the bright, in-your-face '90s-style aesthetic. The Pacific Brett Favre #551 is an easy-to-find card that should be part of any collection. However, the aesthetic and commonality of this card mean prices remain steady. According to SportsCardsPro, the 1991 Pacific rookie card sells for $62.25 at the top of the market, whereas grade 9 sells for $18.00. An ungraded version of the card is worth $2, and at least one is sold daily. 

1991 Upper Deck Brett Favre #13 

Without an action shot as the image, this card is less valuable than it could be. However, the affordability of this card can be an appealing factor to many collectors. Although you may not be selling it for profit, as a collector, this bargain rookie card could slip seamlessly into your collection without breaking the bank.

In 2022, the SportsCardsPro databasereported that the Brett Favre rookie card costs around $2.50 ungraded, but could go as high as $61 when graded Gem Mint 10. However, it's not uncommon for this card to fetch higher numbers, and on September 9, 2022, one card sold for $100.

1991 Pro Set Platinum Brett Favre #290

Another trendy Brett Favre rookie card. If there's any Favre football card you can consider a "must-have," it's this one. The official NFL card has a classic aesthetic and is highly popular with collectors. While still relatively inexpensive and easy to find, the platinum version of this card is an excellent addition to any collection. 

The Pro Set Platinum version is being traded for a small but exciting amount of money in 2022. According to the SportsCardsPro database, a grade 10 version of the card was sold for $46 on the 11th of September. The average Gem Mint grade 10 edition goes for $54.00, but an ungraded card currently goes for only $1.25.

1991 Star Pics Brett Favre Auto #65

The Star Pics Brett Favre RC Auto is the first autographed card ever from the quarterback, which adds differentiation to his other rookie cards and significant value. We checked the web to search what the 1991 Star Pics #65 card was fetching in 2022, and SportsCardsPro.com stated and a non-autographed version that's ungraded is worth around $2, whereas a grade 9 version will bring around $15. 

However, it didn't stop there. If you can get your hands on a grade 10 version of this card, it will fetch around $27. SportsCardsPro report that two versions of this particular card are sold per week in 2022. The autographed versions are harder to track a firm estimate, but their value is obviously significantly higher than the base versions.

Summary 

Collectors agree that Brett Favre rookie cards can be a lucrative investment and the 2022 sales data confirms this. While some cards are relatively common and low value, a handful of Favre rookie cards stand out from the pack.

If you're looking for help grading Brett Favre cards, we provide elite sports card grading services with fast, high-quality service for all sports cards. Become a CSG member today and start preserving your Brett Favre rookie cards.