Dan Marino Rookie Card Market Guide

Posted on 12/24/2022

Find out about the value of Dan Marino rookie cards, and learn how grading can enhance and authenticate your card collection.

As one of the NFL's top record-breaking quarterbacks of all-time, Dan Marino led the Miami Dolphins to 10 playoff appearances and Super Bowl XIX. By the time he retired in 2000, Marino held numerous NFL passing records, including passing yards (61,361), completions (4,967) and touchdown passes (420). So, how does Marino's incredible pro career translate to his rookie cards and their values? This guide will answer that question and more.

Dan Marino: An Iconic NFL Career

The Beginning of a Legend

After a successful college career with the University of Pittsburgh Panthers, culminating in a 1982 Sugar Bowl win over the Georgia Bulldogs, Marino was chosen as the newly-formed USFL's first draft pick for the Los Angeles Express. However, he chose instead to sign with the NFL's Miami Dolphins. During his 1983 rookie season, he achieved a 96.0 passer rating, had the highest pass completion percentage (58.45%) and had the lowest percentage of interceptions (2.03%). As a result of his breakout performance, he was named Rookie of the Year by Sporting News.

Reaching the Super Bowl

Marino continued to break records the following year, including most touchdown passes (48), which led to the NFL choosing him as the league's MVP that season. After a decisive 45-28 AFC Championship win against the Pittsburgh Steelers, Marino led the Dolphins in Super Bowl XIX where they fell to the San Francisco 49ers. It would be Marino's only Super Bowl appearance of his astounding career. With 155 career wins to his name, Marino is still the winningest quarterback to never win a Lombardi Trophy.

Honors and Achievements

In 1986, Marino became the first quarterback in the NFL to throw 30 or more touchdown passes in three consecutive seasons. During his 17-year career with Miami, he was selected for the Pro Bowl nine times and was named the NFL MVP in 1984 after setting a single-season record of 48 touchdown passes and 5,084 passing yards.

In 2003, he was inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame and, in 2005, the Pro Football Hall of Fame. In 2019, he was chosen for the NFL 100 All-Time Team and hailed as one of the league's ten greatest quarterbacks. 

Investment Potential for Dan Marino Rookie Cards

To today's collectors, it may seem surprising that Dan Marino only had one official rookie card, especially since he played during the 1980s and 1990s when sports cards were massively overproduced. However, relatively few were issued for players back then, and even top draft prospects usually only had one official rookie card. Fortunately for collectors, several "oddball" rookie cards were issued to celebrate Marino's outstanding first-year achievements as well.

Marino was a legendary quarterback with a historic, record-breaking career. Additionally, he continues to be active as a football celebrity in the broadcast booth. These factors contribute to his ongoing popularity and help maintain interest in his memorabilia on the collectibles market.

Further, Marino played his entire career with one of the NFL's most popular teams, the Miami Dolphins. As arguably the Dolphins' greatest and most famous player, Marino's rookie cards should continue to generate interest from both football card collectors and Dolphins fans for years to come. Therefore, Marino's rookie cards are a relatively safe bet to hold their value. Yet, collectors and investors alike will want to follow market trends and do their research as they would for any other investment.

Top Dan Marino Rookie Cards

  • 1984 Topps #123 Dan Marino
  • 1984 Topps Stickers #222 Dan Marino
  • 1984 Topps NFL Star Set #3 Dan Marino
  • 1984 Topps #202 Passing Leaders Dan Marino/Steve Bartkowski
  • 1984 Dolphins Police Dan Marino

Only one of these, #123, is the true official Dan Marino rookie card. However, the other 1984 Topps are also highly sought-after by collectors because they were first-year inserts or "oddball cards" celebrating Marino's debut season. Another first-year card of great interest is the 1984 Dolphins Police card, an unofficial rookie card issued by local law enforcement.

Here's a look at how these cards are trending at online auctions:

1984 Topps #123 Dan Marino ($12,000)

Considered the "official" Dan Marino rookie card, this colorful offering from Topps features an image of Marino in a game wearing the famous all white Dolphins uniform and helmet. Vibrant graphics showcase the photo in an upended black square frame accented with vivid blue and orange. Interestingly, the card also cites his Pro Bowl selection, with "AFC Pro Bowl" highlighted next to the Topps logo.

This example was part of the 264-card 1984 Topps football set, which is considered iconic today since it also includes the rookie card of another NFL all-time great, quarterback John Elway.

PriceGuide.Cards shows Ungraded examples starting at $32 and average graded prices trending from $93 to $179 (grade unspecified). The top price for this card trends at a staggering $12,000 (grade unspecified).

Sports Card Investor shows a recent sale of a Gem Mint 10 that sold on January 29, 2023 for $4,355. 

SportsCardsPro tracks Ungraded examples of this card at around $39. Graded prices range from $56 for Grade 7, $100 for Grade 8 and $300 for Grade 9. Additionally, Grade 9.5 trends for $1,292, while a Gem Mint 10 example trends for $4,687. 

1984 Topps Stickers #222 Dan Marino ($1,575)

Topps Stickers cards provide a fun way to add variety to a sports card collection. This popular example features a gameplay image of first-year player Marino under center and calling out signals before the snap.

This card is especially interesting for collectors because there's only an image framed in gold striping and nothing more. There are no banners, words or logos, and Marino's name isn't even on the front.

At SportsCardsPro, Ungraded examples trend at $18, Grade 8 trends for $32 and Grade 9 trends at $133. Grade 9.5 trends at around $255, while Gem Mint 10 trends for $1,575.

1984 Topps NFL Star Set #3 Dan Marino ($760)

Insert cards are always fun for collectors because they're like getting a mystery gift. They're not part of the regular numbered set and usually have a unique design that is different from the rest of the pack.

This particular Marino fan favorite was an insert card placed inside the 11-card Topps 1984 Star Set. It features an exciting action gameplay shot of the young QB about to throw a pass while being protected by his running back. The image is framed in an eye-catching blue border with white striping and is topped off with a large NFL logo at the lower left of the card.

SportsCardsPro shows prices for this card trending at $13 for Ungraded, $36 for Grade 7, $45 for Grade 8 and $126 for Grade 9. Grade 9.5 trends for around $216, while Gem Mint 10 leaps up to $760.

PriceGuide.Cards shows this card topping out at $410 (grade unspecified).

1984 Topps #202 Passing Leaders Dan Marino/Steve Bartkowski ($300)

Marino gets to share the spotlight in this bit of football history from Topps. The card honors two passing leaders for the year, Marino and Atlanta Falcons quarterback Steve Bartkowski. While not an official rookie card, it continues to celebrate Marino's record-breaking rookie season.

The card features a split graphic with duo headshots of Marino and Bartkowski. In addition, there's a large white banner with "Passing Leaders" on top and "1983 NFL" in red and yellow at the top left corner.

On PriceGuide.Cards, examples range from $2 to $75 for Ungraded versions and their top recorded price is $300 (grade unspecified).

1984 Dolphins Police Dan Marino ($230)

These cards were given out by Miami law enforcement in 1984. They feature an excellent gameplay action-shot of the young Marino holding the ball and preparing to throw a pass. The image is framed in Miami's iconic team colors of aqua, orange and white.

Given its appealing graphics, this unofficial rookie card is popular among collectors and is an indispensable part of any Marino rookie collection. Interestingly, the Dolphins Police card is also popular with law enforcement memorabilia fans, which gives it an added collectors market.

On SportsCardsPro, Ungraded examples trend for $20, while Grade 7 trends for around $50, Grade 8 for $71 and Grade 9 for $82. At Grade 9.5, prices climb to $135, while a Gem Mint 10 example trends for $230.

Where Can I Find Dan Marino Rookie Cards?

You can find Dan Marino rookie cards at a wide range of online auction sites, including:

In addition, you'll find Dan Marino rookie cards at sports card and memorabilia shows, which are held year-round across the country. You can do a Google search or check with community forums, collector sites and social media pages to find out about upcoming shows near you.

How Are Dan Marino Rookie Cards Graded?

Sports and trading cards are graded using a numeric grading system that ranges from Ungraded to Perfect 10. Here's how it works:

Perfect 10: Perfect 10 cards are the absolute best in existence. They've achieved Gem Mint grades across all four grading criteria: corners, edges, surface and centering. These cards are flawless, even when viewed at 10x magnification.

Gem Mint: These cards are perfect and have vivid colors, sharp corners, perfect centering and no flaws or damage.

Grade 9.5: These cards are considered Near-Mint, with usually just one minor flaw.

Grade 9: These cards are in excellent condition, with just a few minor flaws.

Grades 8 and below: These cards may have condition issues or manufacturing flaws and are priced accordingly.

Raw or Ungraded: Raw cards are new to the market. Usually, they've just been removed from their original packaging. Ungraded cards have never been graded and may or may not be new to the collectors market.

As for value, the critical components of any card's value are condition, rarity and collector demand. However, the collectibles market can fluctuate wildly and unexpectedly. While a card might be exceedingly rare, its market value may stagnate if there's no collector demand for it. Likewise, a more-common card may skyrocket in price if collectors are clamoring for memorabilia from that player.

During the "junk wax" era of the 1980s and 1990s, when sports cards were over-produced, card collecting experienced a huge collectors boom as new buyers entered the market and started stashing away cards, hoping to one day profit from their investment. As a result, cards that might have become rare are relatively common and easy to find. Yet, the good news is that certain cards remain desirable, especially if they're in Perfect 10 or Gem Mint condition.

Collector interest drives the market — and it's also one of the primary components that fuels values, especially given the popularity of internet auctions. On any given day, two high-roller collectors might get into a bidding war for a card, which could cause the value of that card to skyrocket. Likewise, a player may have a comeback or suddenly become a TV celebrity, which can also impact prices as new fans and collectors start seeking memorabilia for that player.

Should I Get My Sports Cards Graded?

Grading can help establish a recognized quality level for your cards. When you get your cards graded, a professional certification expert will assign your card a grade number and enter the information in an international database. This process not only recognizes your card's quality but also authenticates it.

As you can see from the values listed above, graded cards often sell for higher prices and are typically much easier to sell than Ungraded cards. And even if you don't plan to sell your cards, you can take satisfaction in owning a collection of professionally graded cards that industry experts have fully authenticated.

Whether you plan to keep your cards, sell them, donate them or bequeath them, you can help enhance the quality of your collection by having it graded by professional companies like Certified Sports Guaranty (CSG). With grading, your cards will be certified as authentic, with an established quality rating that will be recognized for generations.

*Any mention of "investment potential" is for entertainment only and should not be construed as investment advice. The Certified Collectibles Group does not provide investment advice and is not liable for any buy, sell or trade decisions made by any parties.

Stay Informed

Want news like this delivered to your inbox once a month? Subscribe to the free CGC eNewsletter today!


You've been subscribed to the CGC eNewsletter.

Unable to subscribe to our eNewsletter. Please try again later.

Articles List

Add CGC Card

Create a Set

Join CGC for free to add cards, track your collection and participate in the CGC Trading Cards Registry or CGC Sports Cards Registry.

Join CGC

Already a member? Sign In
Add to CGC Card Registry Example
Add to CGC Card Registry Example