Pedro Martinez Rookie Card Market Guide

Posted on 3/14/2022

Discover Pedro Martinez’s rookie cards and their current trending values, while learning about grading and how it can potentially increase the value of your collection.

There's no doubt that Pedro Martinez is one of the greatest pitchers in baseball history. He was a dominant force on the mound for almost two decades, and his rookie cards are highly sought-after by collectors. If you're a fan of baseball or collecting memorabilia, you should consider investing in Martinez’s rookie cards. In this article, we will look at the different types of Martinez rookie cards available and the key factors to consider when buying them.

Who Is Pedro Martinez?

Pedro Martinez is a former Major League Baseball pitcher who played for the Los Angeles Dodgers, Montreal Expos, Boston Red Sox, New York Mets and Philadelphia Phillies. Born in October 1971 in Manoguayabo, Dominican Republic, he started his professional MLB career in 1992. He made his big-league debut on September 24, 1992, and played for the Dodgers until 1994, when he was traded to the Montreal Expos. While playing for the Canadian team, Martinez developed into one of the best pitchers in baseball.

In 1998, he signed with the Boston Red Sox, where he continued that success, helping to lead the franchise to its first World Series championship in 86 years. This kickstarted a string of successes for the Red Sox. Though Martinez left the Red Sox in 2004 to play for the Mets and Phillies, the Red Sox continued their momentum and won three more World Series titles in 2007, 2013 and 2018. In 2015, Martinez was inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, and Boston Red Sox fans remember him as one of the greatest players in team history.

Throughout his career, Martinez was known for his fastball (which reached speeds of up to 99 mph), devastating changeup and excellent control. He was a three-time Cy Young Award winner (1999, 2000 and 2002) and an eight-time All-Star. He also won a World Series title with the Red Sox in 2004, making him one of the most decorated pitchers in baseball history.

What Makes Pedro Martinez's Cards So Valuable?

Many factors make Pedro Martinez's cards valuable. They include:

  • Rarity: Pedro Martinez was only a rookie in 1992, so there still weren’t as many sets created, and therefore less rookie cards available.
  • Quality: Martinez's cards are excellent and feature some beautiful artwork or photos of him in action on the field.
  • Condition: The condition of Martinez's rookie cards is also a critical factor that affects their value. Near Mint cards or better can be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars.
  • Autograph: Collectors love autographed versions of Pedro Martinez's rookie cards, as they add an extra layer of authenticity to the card and further increase its value.
  • Career accomplishments: As we mentioned earlier, the decorated pitcher was a three-time Cy Young Award winner and an eight-time All-Star. His career accomplishments and awards make his cards even more desirable to collectors.

Investment Potential

Before you invest in or collect sports cards, there are a few things to consider — the main ones being potential appreciation and their return on investment. However, there are some other factors you should consider:

  • Market trends: Market trends are significant when investing in sports cards, as they will typically dictate the card's value. Trends can be anything from the supply and demand of the card to the current popularity of the team to any events that may have taken place recently (such as championship wins).
  • Card grading: Another essential factor to consider is card grading. Professional graders assign a numerical grade to the card based on its condition, which will help determine its overall value.
  • Special features: Special features, such as autographs, game-used swatches and die-cut cards, can also affect the value of a card.
  • Player popularity: The player's popularity can also influence the card's value. If they are in the news or playing well, this can cause their cards to become more popular, which can lead to a higher price.
  • Sports popularity: The sport's popularity can also influence card prices. If a particular sport is more popular than others, then it is likely that their cards will be sought after and, thus, have a higher value.
  • Historical significance: Historical significance can also affect the value of a card. If it is the first card issued for that particular player or if they achieved something noteworthy, it will be more valuable than other cards.
  • Investment strategy: Lastly, your investment strategy should also be considered. Do you want to buy and hold or flip cards? This can help you determine the type of card most suitable for your investing needs.

The Best Pedro Martinez Rookie Cards

Here are some of the best Pedro Martinez rookie cards to consider when investing or collecting:

1991 Upper Deck Final Edition #2F Pedro Martinez ($1,497)

The top card on our list of Pedro Martinez rookie cards is the 1991 Upper Deck Final Edition. This card features the only close-up image of Pedro, showing his face in full detail. Martinez is seen looking forward and wearing his LA Dodgers hat with a determined expression. The text on the lower right corner reads “Diamond Skills,” making it a standout card among his rookie cards. This card is very rare and carries a hefty price tag, making it one of the most valuable of all of Pedro's rookie cards.

1992 Bowman #82 Pedro Martinez($1,199)

The 1992 Bowman #82 features the most energetic and detailed image of Pedro Martinez as a rookie. He is captured in his full-motion windup, with a blurred stadium behind him and the Bowman “B” logo in the top left corner. The bottom right corner has a simple nameplate for the "Pedro Martinez" text. In contrast to cards with Pedro posing in a static position, this one captures the excitement of his rookie season. This card is rare and highly sought-after by collectors, making it one of the most desirable Martinez rookie cards out there.

1991 ProCards #2971 Pedro Martinez ($676)

The ProCards Baseball base card features a bold, colorful design that will stand out in any rookie card collection. The image of the card is displayed over a yellow notepad-inspired background with a white border. Pedro is featured in his minor league San Antonio Missions uniform, posing for the camera. The card's design makes it an attractive option for any collector who wants to add color and flair to their collection.

1992 Upper Deck #18 Pedro Martinez – Gold Hologram ($400)

The 1992 Upper Deck #18 is another popular Pedro Martinez rookie card. The design features white borders and the Upper Deck logo in the top-right corner. The photo shows Pedro throwing a practice pitch with his arm cocked back, looking ready to let it fly. The image is taken from the side, which gives a unique perspective to the card that is sure to draw attention. A "Star Rookie" logo on the lower left corner is printed, adding to the card's collectability.

1991 California League All-Stars #1 Pedro Martinez ($300)

The California League All-Stars card is a great option for collectors looking for a vintage Pedro Martinez rookie card. The card features a basic design with an image of Pedro on top and a lower third with his name at the bottom. The photo shows Pedro donning his Dodgers gear, posing face-forward with his glove in his hand. This card image is overexposed, giving it a certain vintage charm.

1992 Leaf Gold Leaf Rookies #BC-3 Pedro Martinez ($299)

The Leaf Gold Leaf Rookies card features a unique design that stands out from other Pedro Martinez rookie cards. The card has a thin-lined gold foil embossed border overlayed on top of a full card image, giving the card an eye-catching look. Pedro is featured in his LA Dodgers uniform with his arm cranked back, ready to throw a pitch. This is an excellent card for collectors looking for something special and unique in their collections.

1992 SkyBox AAA #5 Pedro Martinez ($200)

The SkyBox AAA base card is another popular option for collectors. It features a simple design with a basic white border and the SkyBox logo. The card also shows Pedro Martinez in his pre-rookie minor-league days with the Albuquerque Dukes. Pedro is standing, facing forward with a ball in his hand, with the stadium blurred in the background. While not a flashy card, it is affordable for collectors on a budget.

1991 ProCards Tomorrow's Heroes #244 Pedro Martinez ($200)

The ProCards Tomorrow's Heroes card is a standard base card. While there are no bells and whistles, it is an excellent option for collectors looking for an affordable Pedro Martinez rookie card.

The graphic design features a diamond-shaped border, the ProCards logo and team-specific lettering for Martinez's time with the minor league's San Antonio Missions. As a rookie card, this is an attractive and reasonably priced option that would make a great addition to any beginner's collection.

Where Can I Purchase Pedro Martinez Rookie Cards?

Depending on your budget and the type of Pedro Martinez cards that you're looking for, there are a few ways to purchase them:

  • eBay: eBay is an online marketplace that is an excellent source for buying sports cards. You will usually find the widest selection of Pedro Martinez rookie cards available here at various prices.
  • Professional card dealers: Professional card dealers tend to specialize in one particular area or sport, so they are an excellent resource for collectors looking for specific types of cards. They may also be able to offer you more advice on the value and investment potential of certain Pedro Martinez rookie cards.
  • Sports memorabilia stores: If you are looking for Pedro Martinez rookie cards in person, then a sports memorabilia store is your best bet. Many of these stores carry vintage and modern cards, with knowledgeable staff to answer any questions.
  • Collectibles conventions: Collectibles conventions are another great way to find Pedro Martinez rookie cards. These events are typically held in larger cities and offer hundreds of vendors selling collectibles.
  • Private sellers: For collectors looking for rare or hard-to-find Pedro Martinez rookie cards, private sellers may be the way to go. Private sellers typically offer the highest-value cards, so it's essential to research before making any purchases.
  • Auction: Lastly, auctions are your best bet for finding ultra-rare Pedro Martinez rookie cards. Auctions typically offer the highest prices for these cards, so knowing all the details and conditions is essential before bidding.

How Are Pedro Martinez's Rookie Cards Graded?

Professional, independent third-party grading companies usually evaluate sports cards on a 1–10 scale. Each number on the scale represents a different grade and condition, with a Pristine 10 being the best as it's achieved a Gem Mint 10 rating on all four grading metrics. The metrics used to determine grades include:

  • Surface: The surface of a card is graded on its overall condition. This consists of any buffing, scratching and staining that may have occurred over time.
  • Corners: The corners are evaluated for sharpness, roundness and surface wear.
  • Edges: The edges are inspected for chipping, roughness and general wear.
  • Centering: Centering is graded on the uniformity of borders and design elements.

For further information on CGC's 10-point Grading Scale and to find out more about our industry-leading services, visit


Whether you're a first-time collector or an experienced investor, Pedro Martinez rookie cards can be a great addition to your collection. They are rare, have excellent quality and feature some beautiful artwork. Plus, they can appreciate over time if you acquire them in the proper condition and grade.

To make the best purchase, research the baseball card market, understand the grading system and purchase from reputable sellers. Sports card collecting is a fun and rewarding hobby, and Pedro Martinez's cards are some of the best. Good luck in your search for these prized collectibles!

*Any mention of "investment potential" is for entertainment only and should not be construed as investment advice. The Certified Collectibles Group does not provide investment advice and is not liable for any buy, sell or trade decisions made by any parties.

Stay Informed

Want news like this delivered to your inbox once a month? Subscribe to the free CGC eNewsletter today!


You've been subscribed to the CGC eNewsletter.

Unable to subscribe to our eNewsletter. Please try again later.

Articles List

Add CGC Card

Create a Set

Join CGC for free to add cards, track your collection and participate in the CGC Trading Cards Registry or CGC Sports Cards Registry.

Join CGC

Already a member? Sign In
Add to CGC Card Registry Example
Add to CGC Card Registry Example