Jonathan Taylor Rookie Card Market Guide

Posted on 4/15/2023

Get the inside scoop on Jonathan Taylor's rookie cards, learn about grading and investing in them, as well as where to find them with this comprehensive guide.

If you want to invest in Jonathan Taylor rookie cards, there are many options at various price points for you to consider. To make the most informed decision, you must research and understand each card's value. This guide will provide all the expert information you need to make the best investment decisions possible. We'll break down Taylor's career and the investment potential of his cards and then give a list of the top Jonathan Taylor rookie cards.

Who Is Jonathan Taylor?

Jonathan Taylor is one of the top young prospects in the National Football League (NFL). He's a running back for the Indianapolis Colts and is currently gearing up for his fourth professional season.

Jonathan Taylor's College Career

Jonathan Taylor set the New Jersey rushing record in high school, landing him a full-ride scholarship to the University of Wisconsin, where he continued his dominance. In his three years of college football, Taylor produced staggering numbers and is currently 6th all-time in rushing yards despite only playing three seasons. Taylor is the only player in NCAA history to rush for over 6,000 yards in three seasons.

Taylor was awarded the Doak Walker Award in 2018 and 2019, given to the top running back in college football. His success in college was enough to see him drafted 41st overall in the 2020 NFL Draft by the Indianapolis Colts.

Jonathan Taylor's NFL Career

In Jonathan Taylor's first three seasons in the NFL, he showed he has what it takes to be a dominant force. As a rookie, Taylor broke the 1,000-yard rushing mark while contributing 299 receiving yards and 11 touchdowns through 15 games.

In the 2021 NFL season, Taylor led the NFL in rushing yards and touchdowns, broke the single-season rushing record for the Indianapolis Colts and was named a unanimous All-Pro. While he began the season as a backup to Marlon Mack, Taylor's work ethic and natural ability to break tackles and deke defenders quickly allowed him to overtake the role as the full-time starter.

This led to massive expectations for Taylor heading into the 2022 NFL season. He was the number one overall pick in most fantasy football leagues, with expectations of repeating as the league's leading rusher. Unfortunately, his 2022 season didn't go as planned.

Injuries plagued Jonathan Taylor's season, and he only managed to produce 861 rushing yards with four touchdowns before ending his season early in week 16 due to a high ankle sprain. Despite his recent struggles, Taylor is still considered one of the best running backs in the NFL. At only the age of 24, his potential could be limitless.

What Makes Jonathan Taylor's Rookie Cards So Valuable?

When looking at the value of a player's rookie cards, many factors can affect the price. Here are some of the main factors that contribute to the value of an athlete's trading cards:

  • On-Field Production: One of the main factors that can increase a player's rookie card value is if they're able to produce on the field consistently. Jonathan Taylor falls into this category, as we've seen him dominate in college and make an immediate impact in his first three seasons in the NFL. While his third season was underwhelming, to say the least, he still showed glimpses of the player we saw in 2021 and has sky-high expectations for the upcoming NFL season.
  • Career Accomplishments: Another factor affecting a player's rookie card value is their accomplishments, accolades and awards. At only 23 years old, Jonathan Taylor is off to an excellent start. He's already been named to the All-Pro team and secured the rushing title. However, the most significant award in building a player's legacy is the Super Bowl and ultimately being inducted into the Hall of Fame. It is too soon to tell if Taylor can achieve these honors, but it's something to consider when looking at his rookie card value.
  • Limited Supply: The third factor in determining the investment potential for Jonathan Taylor's rookie cards is the number of cards produced. The more copies of a card, the less valuable it becomes. With his popularity rising after the 2021 NFL season, many card companies produced limited editions of his rookie cards, causing them to skyrocket in value. People are always looking for the next big thing, and Taylor's rookie cards have caught many investors' attention.
  • Overall Likeability and Legacy: Lastly, an athlete's rookie card value can be impacted by their popularity amongst fans and their legacy after their career. Jonathan Taylor is still very young, and he has already launched a scholarship program called "Be The Change." The program aims to provide scholarships to college-bound black student-athletes.

Investment Potential for Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards

Investing in any sports card of a big star has the potential to pay off in a big way, and Jonathan Taylor's rookie cards are no exception. Still, it is essential to understand the market and its trends when investing in sports cards. If you don't do your research, you could end up making a bad investment. Here are some factors that may affect the value of his cards:

  • Rarity: The availability of a card affects its value, so rare cards typically have a higher price. Many Jonathan Taylor rookie cards are limited editions and highly sought-after, making them much more valuable than other cards.
  • Condition: The condition of the card is a key factor in determining its value, as any defects or wear can reduce the amount buyers are willing to pay. All Jonathan Taylor rookie cards must be kept in top condition to retain their highest value.
  • Demand: The market demand for a particular card is another factor that can affect its value. If more people want a specific card than available, prices increase until supply and demand match up once again. As one of the top college players of 2020 and having been drafted by the Indianapolis Colts, Taylor has garnered significant interest in his cards among fans, collectors and investors alike.
  • Production Quality: High-quality printing technologies can add significantly to a card's value. These cards often feature special effects (foil stamping and embossing) that stand out from standard mass production methods. Jonathan Taylor rookie cards produced with high-quality methods tend to have higher values than those printed using lower-grade materials or processes.
  • Limited Editions: Many companies produce limited edition versions of famous players' cards, which usually come with extras. Features like autographs or memorabilia pieces can significantly increase the card's value — particularly if they come from an exclusive signing session.

The Best Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards

As a guide to investing in Jonathan Taylor rookie cards, here are some of the rarest and most valuable cards to look out for:

2020 Panini Flawless #115 Jonathan Taylor - Platinum Parallel #’d/1 ($4,525)

The Platinum Parallel kickstarts this list of the best Jonathan Taylor rookie cards, with a value of $4,525. The card features a horizontal design with a white and black color scheme. A patch is placed on the left of the card and is accompanied by an image of Taylor to the right holding the ball with one hand as he slows down before crossing the end zone. What makes this card so special is it's a one-of-one, meaning only one of these cards was produced. This gives the card significant potential to increase in value, as it's incredibly rare.

2020 Donruss Optic #167 Jonathan Taylor - Blue Parallel #’d/179 ($5,277)

Panini Donruss Optic is increasingly popular in the card trading world. The base Jonathan Taylor card isn't considered to be elite. However, the parallels are in high demand. The Blue Parallel is numbered out of 179, has a holographic finish and is the most valuable topping out at $5,277.

2020 Panini Prizm Rookie Autographs #332 Jonathan Taylor - Gold Parallel #’d/10 ($8,262)

Rookie autograph cards automatically increase the value of a card. Add in the popular Prizm Gold Parallel, and you have a winner. The Jonathan Taylor Prizm Rookie Autographs Gold Prizm card is one of the nicest-looking cards from his rookie season. The gold trim and on-card auto make it a great choice for collectors or investors. However, you’ll have to pay a pretty penny to own it since sales have reached upwards of $8,262.

2020 Panini Flawless Shield Signatures #2 Jonathan Taylor - #’d/1 ($10,052)

The Panini Flawless Shield Signature card is constantly among the year's most popular releases and is considered a super-premium NFL card. The Flawless Shield card is a one-of-one that comes with Taylor’s on-card autograph and a rare game-worn NFL logo patch. This card previously sold for over $10,000 and is considered one of the top Jonathan Taylor rookie cards on the market.

2020 Panini Prizm Rookie Autographs #332 Jonathan Taylor - Black Finite Parallel #’d/1 ($19,188)

Panini Prizm has taken over the world of sports trading cards and is often seen as one of the most valuable releases of the year. This lands true with the Jonathan Taylor Panini Prizm rookie card as well. The base version of this Jonathan Taylor rookie card has a chrome finish and is a heavy card stock, giving it the look and feel of a premium card. The image is of Taylor rushing with the ball tucked in his arm. The borders are a unique design that adds to the overall clean look of this card.

However, the true value lies in the parallels and inserts for this collection, specifically the Black Finite Parallel. This is another one-of-one, making it extremely rare, which drives the price up. This particular card has sold for as much as $19,188 for a highly graded copy and is the pinnacle of Jonathan Taylor's rookie cards.

Where Can I Purchase Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards?

If you want to purchase Jonathan Taylor rookie cards, many reputable online dealers specialize in sports memorabilia and collectibles. Here are some of the best places to get your hands on the running back’s rookie cards, based on the rarity of the card:

  • Common Cards: If you're looking for a budget-friendly Jonathan Taylor rookie card, then websites like eBay and Facebook marketplace are great places to start.
  • Rare Cards: Kicking things up a notch, online auctions or hobby shops offer more opportunities to find rarer Jonathan Taylor rookie cards. Many auction sites have graded cards that are certified, which provides a level of comfort when making larger investments.
  • Premium Cards: Premium Jonathan Taylor rookie cards can also be found on established websites, auction sites and hobby shops. Conventions are another excellent way to find premium cards, as the card's rarity and value are usually more emphasized in these events.

How Are Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards Graded?

Trading cards are graded based on a set of standards and criteria by a third-party card grading company. Generally speaking, cards are given a numerical grade that ranges from 1 to 10, with 10 being the highest quality. A higher grade usually denotes an increase in value for the card, as it is often viewed as being in better condition than lower-graded cards. A card's highest rating is a "Pristine 10," which must be inspected through microscopic analysis.

Here are some of the factors that are considered when grading a card:

  • Centering: how well the card has been cut
  • Edges: any chipping or wear
  • Surface: how well it has kept its gloss and finish
  • Corners: any dings, dents, curling, etc.

For further information on CGC's 10-point Grading Scale and to find out more about our industry-leading services, visit

Investing in Jonathan Taylor Rookie Cards

If you're looking to invest in Jonathan Taylor cards, there are many things to consider. The main factors to keep in mind are the card's grade, rarity and popularity. Rare cards are usually the most sought-after, as they tend to hold their value over time. It's also important to ensure you purchase your cards from a reputable dealer or website to guarantee authenticity and quality.

While there's no certainty that Taylor's career will be successful, investing in his rookie cards can be a great way to capitalize on future value. He's still young but has already secured a rushing title, been named an All-Pro and has solid potential moving forward. Happy investing!

*Any mention of "investment potential" is for entertainment only and should not be construed as investment advice. The Certified Collectibles Group does not provide investment advice and is not liable for any buy, sell or trade decisions made by any parties.

Stay Informed

Want news like this delivered to your inbox once a month? Subscribe to the free CGC eNewsletter today!


You've been subscribed to the CGC eNewsletter.

Unable to subscribe to our eNewsletter. Please try again later.

Articles List

Add CGC Card

Create a Set

Join CGC for free to add cards, track your collection and participate in the CGC Trading Cards Registry or CGC Sports Cards Registry.

Join CGC

Already a member? Sign In
Add to CGC Card Registry Example
Add to CGC Card Registry Example